AI tool showdown: 3 tools, 3 tasks, 1 verdict
Employers expect you to know which AI tool to reach for. Run the same 3 tasks through 3 different AI chatbots (9 runs total), score every run, and defend a verdict with evidence.
Posted by The AI Internships
The work brief
- 01Pick 3 different tasks: one writing, one reasoning/maths, one in Hindi/Marathi or about your local area.
- 02Run each task on 3 tools (e.g. ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, Perplexity, Claude) — same prompt each time.
- 03Score all 9 runs in a matrix (accuracy, usefulness, tone) and screenshot the interesting ones.
- 04Write a verdict: which tool for which kind of task, and why.
What you’ll produce
Submission standard
Submit your 3 tasks, the full 9-run scoring matrix, screenshots as evidence, and your verdict. Make sure your screenshot shows your own logged-in account and the date, and paste a public share link to at least one run.
Your 3 tasks (exact prompts used)
Written responseRequiredScoring matrix: 3 tools × 3 tasks with scores and one-line notes
Written responseRequiredScreenshot of the most surprising difference between tools
Screenshot must show the tool's real interface, your logged-in account/handle, AND a visible date/time.
Image uploadRequiredYour verdict: which tool for what, and why
Written responseRequired
You’ll complete these inside your private workspace.
What you must submit as proof
This brief requires evidence an AI can’t fabricate.
Public share link to at least one of your nine runs
A ChatGPT/Gemini/Perplexity 'Share' link to one run that also appears as a cell in your matrix.
Public linkRequired
Submissions without this evidence cannot be submitted.
Protect other people in your proof. Blur faces, names, phone numbers and email addresses before you upload, and refer to anyone you worked with by role or number ("Listener 1", "the stall owner"). Your proof is only ever used to check your work — it is never published, never appears on your certificate, and is never shown in your public portfolio.
How your work is evaluated
The passing benchmark is 70/100.
Fair, real comparison
29%Same prompts across tools; scores reflect actual runs, not vibes.
Evidence
14%The screenshot genuinely shows a tool difference.
Judgement
29%The verdict is specific and follows from the matrix.
Runs are real and first-party
29%Auto-fail if the screenshot hides the account/date or the share link is missing or doesn't match a matrix cell (invented runs).
How we grade your AI usage
Using AI is the point — it’s the skill this certificate proves. You’ll answer three short questions about how you used it: what you asked, what was wrong with its first answer, and what you changed. Specific, honest answers score high. “I pasted the brief and submitted the answer” scores near zero.